Blog / OR efficiency

Operating Room Management: The Operating Model Behind a 37 Percent Margin Center

The schedule, not the payer mix, explains most of the gap between a 13 percent center and a 37 percent one.

Operating room management benchmarks for 2027: block utilization, first-case starts, turnover, and the cost data that closes the margin gap.

Operating Room Management: The Operating Model Behind a 37 Percent Margin Center

Operating room management is the difference between a surgery center that earns 12.8 percent EBITDA and one that earns 37.3 percent, and the gap shows up in the block schedule before it shows up on the income statement (Avanza). Across more than 450 centers, 42 percent of blocked OR time goes unused (HST Pathways, 2024). That is not a staffing problem or a payer problem. It is a scheduling and measurement problem, and it is the single largest lever most centers are not pulling.

This matters more in 2027 than it did five years ago. Medicare added 560 procedures to the ASC covered list for 2026, 271 of them pulled off the inpatient only list (CMS, November 2025). More case volume is now payable in a center. The centers that convert that volume into margin will be the ones whose rooms already run close to full, not the ones that simply add surgeons to a loose schedule.

The Margin Gap Is an Operating Problem

Start with what separates a small center from a large one. SIS found EBITDA margins of 12.8 percent for centers under 3 million dollars in revenue against 37.3 percent for centers over 9 million (Avanza). Revenue size correlates with margin, but revenue size is a proxy. What the larger centers actually have is purchasing scale, staffing flexibility, and payer contracting teams, three things a single physician-owned center usually lacks (SIS, 2019; Avanza, 2022).

What a single center can build on its own is discipline in the four numbers that drive room output: block utilization, first-case on-time starts, turnover time, and cases per OR per day. None of the four requires capital. All four require someone to measure them every month and act on what they show.

The Four Numbers That Move Together

Block utilization is minutes of actual cases inside a surgeon's block, divided by block minutes, measured by surgeon, every month. The target is 70 percent or better; the average center runs well below that, with 42 percent of block time going unused (HST Pathways, 2024). We cover the formula and the three reasons centers miss it in Block Utilization: The Formula, the 2027 Benchmark and the Three Reasons Centers Miss It.

First-case on-time starts set the tone for the rest of the day. The practical floor is 90 percent; the median center sits near 64.3 percent, with the 90th percentile reaching 88.3 percent (Operating Room Benchmarking Collaborative, via OR Manager). One late first case pushes every case behind it, overtime included. The detail on what the best centers do differently is in First Case On-Time Starts: What the Best ASCs Hit and How They Do It.

Turnover time is patient out to next patient in, by room and by case type. The gold standard is under 7 minutes for short routine cases and under 10 for complex ones, against a survey median of 28.5 minutes (SIS, 2019; OR Manager). Twenty extra minutes across five cases is a sixth case not done. See Turnover Time in the ASC: Benchmarks by Specialty and the Schedule Changes That Cut It for the specialty-level numbers.

Cases per OR per day averages 4.4, with centers completing about 19.4 cases a day in total (SIS, 2019). This is the output number the other three roll up into, and it is the one a board actually wants to see move.

Where the Hours Go

The table below lays out the core operating benchmarks side by side. Use it as the baseline for your own monthly scorecard, not as a target you report once a year.

Core OR efficiency benchmarks (HST Pathways, 2024; Operating Room Benchmarking Collaborative via OR Manager; Surgical Information Systems, 2019)
MetricBenchmarkWhat the average center runs
Block utilization70 percent or better42 percent of block time unused across 450+ centers
First case on-time starts90 percent practical floorMedian 64.3 percent, 90th percentile 88.3 percent
Turnover timeUnder 7 minutes short cases, under 10 complexSurvey median 28.5 minutes
Cases per OR per day4.4 average19.4 cases a day per center
EBITDA margin20 to 30 percent well-run12.8 percent under 3 million in revenue, 37.3 percent over 9 million

Reading the table by row instead of by column is the useful habit. A center with good block utilization but a 25-minute turnover is still losing cases it could run. A center with fast turnover but a 50 percent first-case start rate is losing the first hour of every day before turnover even matters. Prime time, not raw room hours, is the number that ties these together; we cover that distinction in OR Prime Time Utilization: What It Is and Why It Beats Raw Utilization.

Case Costing Turns the Schedule Into a Budget

Operating room management without cost data tells you whether the room ran. It does not tell you whether the case made money. Supplies run 26.4 percent of net revenue at the median center and 36.8 percent at the 90th percentile (Avanza, 2022). Salaries and wages run 29 percent at the median (Avanza, 2022). Those two lines alone take more than half of every collected dollar before rent, anesthesia, or billing.

The fix is costing every case from actual consumption, not the preference card, and loading labor by minutes in the room rather than by shift. SIS puts the gold standard at 21.6 percent of collections for supplies and 23.5 percent for labor, with 14.4 staff hours per case across all roles (SIS, 2019). A center sitting at the Avanza 90th percentile for supplies instead of the SIS gold standard is spending meaningfully more per case on the exact same procedure, and the gap compounds across thousands of cases a year.

This is also where new covered procedures from the 2026 rule get evaluated. A procedure with a strong contribution margin earns a block. One that does not should not get added just because Medicare now pays for it in a center. The full method for building this out is in our pillar guide on Operating Room Utilization.

When Operating Room Consulting Earns Its Fee

Some centers run this audit themselves with the systems they already have. Others bring in outside operating room consulting to pull twelve months of data, calculate the benchmarks, and rank the leaks in weeks rather than months, especially ahead of a renegotiation or a certificate of need filing. Thirty-five states plus the District of Columbia run some form of certificate of need program, and several exempt ASCs or use lighter review, so the regulatory path varies by state (AHPA/NCSL, 2025).

Management companies that run this work commonly charge a fee in the range of 4 to 7 percent of net revenue, in addition to an equity stake (industry convention, commonly reported). Whether that fee is worth paying depends on what it replaces: if it buys purchasing scale, staffing flexibility across sites, and a contracting team a single center cannot build on its own, it is doing the same job that revenue size does for a large center. If it only buys a report, the center can usually produce that report with its own billing and scheduling data.

Site neutrality is part of why this decision matters now. Medicare policy has moved toward paying the same rate for the same service regardless of site of care, and hospital outpatient rates are generally higher than ASC rates for the same procedure today (MedPAC). As that gap narrows, the centers with clean cost data will be the ones who can show a payer, or a hospital partner, exactly what they deliver for less.

What to do this quarter

  • Pull twelve months of case, payer, and schedule data and calculate block utilization, first-case on-time starts, and turnover time by surgeon and by room. Do not fix anything yet; just see the numbers against the benchmarks above.
  • Announce a release-or-lose rule for block time at 48 to 72 hours, name one person who owns first-case readiness, and move first-case patient arrival 30 minutes earlier.
  • Cost your top 20 procedures from actual supply consumption, not the preference card, and rank them by contribution margin before deciding which new 2026 covered procedures are worth a block.

Make your ASC more profitable

Sigmatic is a team of ASC consultants who use our own technology to manage surgery centers: better margins, better workflows, and a real-time view of cost per case and utilization that keeps the gains in place. If the numbers in this article look like your center, book a free 30-minute consultation and we will go through your own figures and show you where the margin is. Read the Operating Room Utilization guide, grab the free PDF, The 2027 ASC State of the Union: maximizing profit on razor-thin margins, from the form on this page, or email [email protected].

Free guide

The 2027 ASC State of the Union: Maximizing profit on razor-thin margins

16 pages of charts: the market, the 2026 reimbursement rules, the benchmarks that separate a 13 percent margin from a 37 percent one, a case costing method you can run this month and a 90-day plan.

One email with the PDF, then the occasional note on ASC margins. Unsubscribe any time.

Before you go

Want a more profitable ASC?

Book a free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers, or leave your email and we will send the 2027 guide first.

Make your ASC more profitable.

A free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers: where the margin is, what to fix first. No obligation.