Preference Card Management: The Supply Cost Lever Most Centers Never Pull
Why the gap between a well-run card and a sloppy one can run close to a million dollars a year at a mid-size center.
Preference card management explains the 16-point supply cost gap between ASCs. Benchmarks, process and a 90-day fix from Sigmatic case costing data.

Preference card management is the single biggest lever most surgery centers have over supply cost, and most centers never pull it. The spread between a center at the 25th percentile and one at the 90th percentile for supply cost as a share of net revenue is 16 points: 20.6% against 36.8% (Avanza, 2022). On a $6 million center, that gap is close to a million dollars a year, and most of it is not volume. It is the card.
A preference card tells the circulating nurse what to open before the surgeon walks in. It is a projection, written once and rarely revisited, and it drives what gets opened whether or not it gets used. Every unused suture, every extra tray, every implant size pulled just in case is a cost the card created and the case never needed.
The Supply Line Nobody Reconciles
Supplies are the largest controllable line on most ASC income statements. At the median center they run 26.4% of net operating revenue, with a quarter of centers above 30.8% and the 90th percentile at 36.8% (Avanza, 2022). Surgical Information Systems puts its gold standard lower still, at 21.6% of collections, or about $456 a case (SIS, 2019). The distance between that number and the 90th percentile is not a different patient population. It is preference cards, implant pricing and waste.
| Percentile | Supply cost, share of net revenue |
|---|---|
| 25th percentile | 20.6% |
| Median | 26.4% |
| 75th percentile | 30.8% |
| 90th percentile | 36.8% |
| SIS gold standard | 21.6% of collections, about $456 per case |
What Preference Card Management Actually Involves
Preference card management is not a one-time cleanup. It is the discipline of keeping every card current with what a procedure actually consumes, by surgeon, reviewed on a set schedule, with data behind every line. Three things have to be true for it to work:
- Consumption is counted, not assumed. What gets opened and used at the end of the case is the real cost, not what the card lists at the start.
- Cards are compared across surgeons doing the same procedure. Two surgeons doing the same total joint with a $400 supply gap is not a clinical difference. It is a card difference, and it needs a conversation with the data on the table.
- Someone owns the review. Without a named owner and a cadence, cards drift back to padded within a year of any cleanup.
This is case costing applied to one line item: start from collections, capture what was actually opened rather than what the card projects, and rank the results by procedure and surgeon. For the full method, from net revenue per case down to contribution margin, see case costing for surgery centers.
Where the Variance Hides, by Specialty
The size of the opportunity depends on specialty mix. Orthopedics and spine run supply costs near 30% of revenue because of implants, while GI and ophthalmology run 12 to 15%, on the same benchmark data. A center heavy in total joints has more dollars in play per case, but also more lines on the card that nobody has priced against the current contract in months. For a specialty-by-specialty breakdown of where supply dollars go, see Supply Cost per Case by Specialty.
Implants deserve separate treatment inside preference card management, because they rarely behave like a normal card line. Vendor pricing varies by who negotiated it and when, and a card that lists an implant by brand rather than by specification can lock in last year's price long after a better one exists. Reviewing the top 20 implants against the current contract, every quarter, is a narrower task than rebuilding every card at once, and it tends to be worth more per hour spent.
Turning Cards Into Case Cost Data
Preference card management only works as a system if the numbers feed back into case costing, and case costing only works if the systems holding the data talk to each other: the EMR for consumption, the billing system for collections, materials management for invoice pricing. Centers running this on spreadsheets pulled by hand can still do it, but it takes days each month instead of minutes. For a look at which systems handle this reconciliation well and which leave it to staff, see ASC Software in 2027.
The practical sequence for most centers: cost the top 10 to 20 procedures by volume using actual consumption, rank surgeons doing the same procedure by supply cost per case, standardize the card for the biggest gaps first, and reprice the top implants and supplies against the current contract at the same time. None of this requires new equipment or new staff. It requires someone with the authority to have the conversation and the data to back it.
The payoff is not only lower supply cost. A center that can show its real cost per case, with cards that match actual consumption, walks into a payer renegotiation with a number the payer cannot produce itself. As site neutral payment policy and flat payer rate updates keep pressure on margin, a center that knows its supply cost down to the card is in a stronger position for that conversation than one that does not. The margin math behind that pressure is covered in ASC EBITDA Margins.
What to do this quarter
- Pull actual consumption data, not preference card listings, for the top 10 procedures by volume, and calculate supply cost per case by surgeon for each one.
- Find every pair of surgeons doing the same procedure with a supply cost gap, and bring the card for the lower-performing one into a standardization conversation, with the numbers on the table.
- Reprice the top 20 implants and supplies against the current contract, request updated quotes on the five largest, and set a recurring quarterly date for the next review.
Related reading
- Case Costing for Surgery Centers
- ASC vs HOPD: How Reimbursement Differs for the Most Common Procedures
- ASC Software in 2027: An Honest Comparison of EMR, Billing and Analytics Tools
- Supply Cost per Case by Specialty: Orthopedics, GI, Ophthalmology and Spine
- The ASC resource hub: every Sigmatic guide on ambulatory surgery centers
Make your ASC more profitable
Sigmatic is a team of ASC consultants who use our own technology to manage surgery centers: better margins, better workflows, and a real-time view of cost per case and utilization that keeps the gains in place. If the numbers in this article look like your center, book a free 30-minute consultation and we will go through your own figures and show you where the margin is. Read the Case Costing for Surgery Centers guide, grab the free PDF, The 2027 ASC State of the Union: maximizing profit on razor-thin margins, from the form on this page, or email [email protected].
Free guide
The 2027 ASC State of the Union: Maximizing profit on razor-thin margins
16 pages of charts: the market, the 2026 reimbursement rules, the benchmarks that separate a 13 percent margin from a 37 percent one, a case costing method you can run this month and a 90-day plan.
Before you go
Want a more profitable ASC?
Book a free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers, or leave your email and we will send the 2027 guide first.
Make your ASC more profitable.
A free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers: where the margin is, what to fix first. No obligation.