The Margin podcast cover art

The Margin · Analytics

Supply Cost per Case by Specialty: Orthopedics, GI, Ophthalmology and Spine

Episode 14 · November 4, 2026 · 7 min

Your blended supply cost percentage is hiding where the real money leaks out of your ASC. We break apart supply cost per case by specialty to show why ortho and spine run near thirty percent of revenue while GI and ophthalmology sit at twelve to fifteen, and what actually separates well run programs from sloppy ones.

Chapters:
0:06 Cold Open
0:31 The Benchmark Numbers
1:43 Why Ortho and Spine Run High
2:57 Why GI and Ophthalmology Run Low
3:58 How to Build the Number and Where the Gap Lives
5:23 What to Do This Quarter
6:16 Close

Free guide, The 2027 ASC State of the Union: https://sigmatic.ai/guide
Book a free consultation: https://sigmatic.ai/contact

#asc #surgerycenter #ambulatorysurgery #healthcarefinance #orutilization #supplychain #orthopedics #revenuecyclemanagement

Chapters

  1. 00:06 Cold Open
  2. 00:31 The Benchmark Numbers
  3. 01:43 Why Ortho and Spine Run High
  4. 02:57 Why GI and Ophthalmology Run Low
  5. 03:58 How to Build the Number and Where the Gap Lives
  6. 05:23 What to Do This Quarter
  7. 06:16 Close

Transcript

Read the full transcript Every episode is transcribed, searchable, and quotable. Plain text

Sigmatic: Quick question. What explains most of that gap? It's supply cost per case. And here's the part that trips people up. there isn't one right answer for what that number should be. So today we're splitting supply cost per case apart by specialty, showing you where the real gaps hide, and giving you three things to do this quarter that don't require new equipment or new staff.

Sigmatic: Let's start with the raw numbers, because these belong on a page you check every month. Across all specialties, the median center runs supply cost at twenty six point four percent of net operating revenue. That comes from a twenty twenty two survey by Avanza Healthcare Strategies. At the twenty fifth percentile, centers run twenty point six percent. At the ninetieth percentile, it's thirty six point eight percent. That's a sixteen point spread between a well run center and one that isn't. On a six million dollar center, that gap is close to a million dollars a year, and almost none of it comes from how sick your patients are. It comes from preference cards, implant pricing, and plain waste. There's also a tighter number worth knowing. Surgical Information Systems published what they call the gold standard back in twenty nineteen. twenty one point six percent of collections, or about four hundred fifty six dollars a case. I'll be straight with you, these are the two surveys most operators still lean on, because nobody has published anything newer at this level of specialty detail. And here's the thing nobody tells you. none of these blended figures tell you what your center should actually spend. It's specialty mix.

Sigmatic: Orthopedics and spine run close to thirty percent of revenue in supply cost, and the reason is one word. implants. They're priced device by device, negotiated vendor by vendor, and a lot of centers lock into a surgeon's preferred brand before anyone ever checks the invoice against the actual contract. A single total joint case can carry an implant cost bigger than the entire supply budget for two G I, short for gastrointestinal, cases combined. That's not a red flag by itself, that's just what ortho and spine look like. What actually separates a well run ortho program from a sloppy one isn't whether implants are expensive. It's whether somebody is pricing those implants against a negotiated contract every quarter, or just paying whatever number sits on the rep's invoice that day. And this is getting more urgent, not less. Supply chain costs were projected to climb another two point four one percent in twenty twenty six, stacked on top of three straight years of inflation already baked in. For a high supply specialty like ortho or spine, that increase lands in real dollars a lot harder than it does in a low supply specialty. Which is exactly why ortho and spine need their own line on your report, not a blended number hiding what's actually happening.

Sigmatic: Now flip to G I and ophthalmology. Those specialties run twelve to fifteen percent of revenue in supply cost, because cataract cases and G I cases use standardized, lower cost disposables. On paper, that looks almost relaxing compared to ortho. Here's where I'd push back on your own comfort though. check the volume before you relax. A center doing four thousand cataract cases a year can lose more total dollars to a few cents of waste per case than an ortho program loses to one badly negotiated implant contract, simply because the case count is so much higher. A few cents, times four thousand, adds up fast. So a low percentage doesn't mean low attention. It just means the lever is different. In ortho, you're negotiating contracts. In G I and ophthalmology, you're standardizing supplies and tightening volume discipline. Same metric, completely different fix, depending on the specialty. That's the whole argument for splitting the number out instead of staring at the blended average on your income statement.

Sigmatic: A few rules we hold to. Start from collections, not charges, when you calculate net revenue per case by procedure and payer. Count what was actually opened and used in the case, not what the preference card lists. The card is a guess. The count is the truth. Price implants separately, case by case, against your current contract, not against whatever the rep invoiced that day in the room. Then rank procedures and surgeons by contribution margin, with ortho and spine on their own page, completely separate from G I and ophthalmology. Here's where most of that gap between the low end and the high end actually lives. two things. preference card variance and implant pricing discipline. That's it. Not new equipment, not more staff. That's not a clinical difference. Put both surgeons' numbers side by side and suddenly it's a conversation, not an argument. This same case cost data is also what makes a payer negotiation credible, especially now that site neutral policy is pushing hospital and A S C rates closer together, and the expanded covered procedures list is pulling more implant heavy cases into centers that may not have priced them correctly yet. We've written more on building out case costing properly, on how this connects to E B I T D A margin alongside staff hours per case and block utilization, and on how anesthesia cost fits the same per case discipline. The links are in the blog, click over and check them out.

Sigmatic: Here's what we'd actually do this quarter if you haven't split this number by specialty in the last twelve months. First, pull the last quarter of case data and calculate supply cost per case separately for ortho and spine, G I, and ophthalmology, or whatever your actual mix looks like. Compare each one to its specialty benchmark, not the blended number. Second, take the top twenty implants used that quarter and price every single one against your current vendor contract. Flag anything priced off a rep's invoice instead of the actual contract, and request a fresh quote on the five biggest dollar items. Third, find the two surgeons with the biggest supply cost gap on the exact same procedure. Schedule a fifteen minute review of their preference cards, with the cost data sitting right in front of both of them. Not an ambush, a conversation. Three steps. They need someone willing to pull the data and have the conversation.

Sigmatic: Supply cost per case isn't glamorous. Split it by specialty, price your implants against the contract, and have the hard conversations with the data on the table instead of hiding behind a blended average. If you want to make your A S C more profitable, book a free consultation with us at sigmatic dot A I. And grab our free guide, The twenty twenty seven A S C State of the Union. The links are in the show notes. Thanks for spending this time with us. We'll see you next time on The Margin.

After the episode

Want a more profitable ASC?

Book a free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers, or leave your email and we will send the 2027 guide first.

Make your ASC more profitable.

A free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers: where the margin is, what to fix first. No obligation.