The Margin podcast cover art

The Margin · Medical

Spine in the ASC: Which Procedures, Which Payers and What Margin

Episode 40 · November 4, 2026 · 9 min

The 2026 Medicare rule just added hundreds of procedures to the ASC covered list, and spine is the specialty everyone wants to chase. But a code landing on that list says nothing about whether the implant cost, payer rate, and labor actually leave you a margin.

Chapters:
0:06 Cold Open
0:38 What Changed in the 2026 Rule
2:11 The Implant Math
4:01 The Payer Conversation
5:55 Building a Pro Forma That Survives Reality
7:18 What to Do This Quarter
8:06 Close

Free guide, The 2027 ASC State of the Union: https://sigmatic.ai/guide
Book a free consultation: https://sigmatic.ai/contact

#asc #surgerycenter #ambulatorysurgery #healthcarefinance #orutilization #spinesurgery #medicarerules #implantcosts

Chapters

  1. 00:06 Cold Open
  2. 00:38 What Changed in the 2026 Rule
  3. 02:11 The Implant Math
  4. 04:01 The Payer Conversation
  5. 05:55 Building a Pro Forma That Survives Reality
  6. 07:18 What to Do This Quarter
  7. 08:06 Close

Transcript

Read the full transcript Every episode is transcribed, searchable, and quotable. Plain text

Sigmatic: Here's a sentence that should make every A S C administrator sit up straight. I'm talking about the twenty twenty-six Medicare rule, the one that added a huge wave of procedures to the A S C covered list. Spine is the specialty everyone's excited about right now. It's also the specialty most likely to quietly lose you money if you don't do your homework first. So let's talk about why a code showing up on a covered list is not the same thing as a code that actually covers an implant and a room.

Sigmatic: Here's what actually happened. Medicare added five hundred sixty procedures and thirty-five ancillary services to the A S C covered procedures list for twenty twenty-six. Two hundred seventy-one of those came straight off what's called the inpatient only list, the list of procedures that used to require a hospital stay. Musculoskeletal procedures went first in that phase-out, and a brand new payment category got created just for them, called Level Seven. On top of that, the base A S C payment update went up about two point six percent for centers that meet their quality reporting requirements. Miss that reporting and you lose two full percentage points off your annual update, which is not a rounding error. Site neutrality also got wider, meaning certain hospital outpatient departments now get paid at the physician fee schedule rate instead of the hospital rate for drug administration. None of those four changes, by itself, tells you what a specific spine procedure nets after you pay for the implant. But put them together and you see why spine volume is moving toward A S Cs faster than almost any other specialty right now. One more thing before you build next year's budget off this year's list. The inpatient only phase-out runs three years, and musculoskeletal went first, which means more spine codes are probably moving in the next two rule cycles. Check the twenty twenty-seven final rule before you lock a spine pro forma to the twenty twenty-six list. And if you want to see how the exact same code can price completely differently depending on whether it's done in the A S C or the hospital outpatient department, we've written about that comparison. I'll put the links in the description.

Sigmatic: Now let's talk about why spine is the specialty to get right, not just the specialty to add. Across every specialty we track, supplies eat up about twenty-six point four percent of net revenue at the median center, and that climbs to thirty-six point eight percent at the ninetieth percentile. Spine and orthopedics sit way up at the high end of that range, running close to thirty percent of revenue, almost entirely because of implants. Compare that to G I and ophthalmology, which run twelve to fifteen percent of revenue because there's no hardware going into the patient. That gap is basically the implant line and nothing else. Here's an illustration using an industry benchmark. On a two thousand dollar case, drugs and supplies typically run about four hundred thirty-two dollars, call it twenty-one point six percent of collections. Staff labor runs about four hundred seventy dollars, or twenty-three point five percent. That's before you even add implant cost. On a spine case, the implant line alone can equal or beat both of those put together. So when a new musculoskeletal code shows up on the covered list with no implant cost built into your pro forma, that's not a margin projection, that's a guess wearing a spreadsheet. Here's how we actually cost a case, and it's simple to describe and genuinely tedious to do well. Start from what was actually collected, by procedure code and by payer. Count what was actually used in the room, not what the preference card says should have been used. Price the implant off the real invoice, because for spine that's the single biggest line item and the one almost nobody tracks case by case. Load labor by actual minutes in the room. Spread room time and overhead per scheduled O R minute. Do all of that at the code level and the surgeon level, because two surgeons doing the exact same fusion code can have wildly different implant costs. If you want the full specialty by specialty breakdown, including where ophthalmology and G I land next to spine, we've laid it out separately. The links are in the blog, click over and check them out.

Sigmatic: Now let's talk money, specifically the conversation you have to have with a payer before that first new spine case runs. Most commercial payers price A S C procedures as some multiple of the Medicare rate. Here's the catch. A code that just moved onto the covered list in twenty twenty-six might not have a commercial rate attached to it yet at all. So the first time a surgeon wants to do that new fusion code, you're not collecting a payment, you're starting a negotiation. The centers that walk into that room with cost per case data instead of just a rate sheet are the ones asking for the right thing. For spine, the ask that actually moves the needle is an implant carve-out. That means payment at invoice cost plus a handling percentage, kept separate from the base procedure rate. A flat percentage of Medicare doesn't care that one surgeon's cage costs one thousand eight hundred dollars and another surgeon's costs three thousand four hundred dollars for the exact same code. Without a carve-out, your center eats that difference no matter who's in the room that day. When you sit down with a payer, bring three things. Bring contribution margin by procedure and by payer, so you can show exactly which spine codes are losing money at the current rate. Bring your volume by payer for the past twelve months, plus the new codes your spine surgeons actually plan to perform. And bring a side by side comparison against the hospital outpatient department rate for the same procedure, because Medicare and most commercial payers already pay less in the A S C, and site neutrality is pushing hospital rates down even further. One more thing worth saying out loud. If a management company is bringing a spine program into your center, they commonly charge a management fee somewhere in the range of four to seven percent of net revenue, on top of taking an equity stake. That fee comes out before your implant carve-out ever starts helping you. Model that in before you sign anything, not after your first quarterly distribution shows up smaller than you expected.

Sigmatic: So how do you actually build a spine pro forma that survives contact with reality, not the average one? The industry benchmark says A S C E B I T D A margin runs about twelve point eight percent for centers under three million dollars in revenue, and climbs to thirty-seven point three percent for centers above nine million. That spread is real, but it doesn't tell you which side of it your new spine line is going to land on. The pro forma that actually holds up is built on the contribution margin of the specific codes your surgeons will perform, priced against the payer mix you can actually sign, with implants costed off the real invoice instead of the preference card. One more wrinkle, and it matters a lot if you're adding rooms. Certificate of need rules apply in thirty-five states plus the District of Columbia. Some of those states exempt A S Cs entirely or use a lighter review for added capacity, but you need to check that before the feasibility study, not during it. Here's the honest gut check. If your center already tracks the ten core benchmarks from case volume all the way to E B I T D A margin, adding spine is just a question of whether the new codes clear the same bar as your existing case mix. If you're not tracking those numbers monthly already, spine is the worst specialty to find that out the hard way, because it carries the highest supply cost exposure of anything in the building. We've written about what a healthy E B I T D A margin actually looks like and where centers typically leak money. The links are below, I will put them in the show notes.

Sigmatic: So here's what we'd actually do this quarter if we were sitting in your office. First, pull every spine code your surgeons performed in the hospital over the past twelve months and check each one against the twenty twenty-six covered procedures list. Then go confirm the twenty twenty-seven update before you budget a single one of them, because this list keeps moving. Second, cost your current spine cases by the actual implant invoice, not the preference card, and rank them by contribution margin, broken out by surgeon and by payer. Third, take your bottom three spine codes by margin to the payer that sends you the most volume, and ask for an implant carve-out at invoice cost plus handling. Bring the cost data from step two to back it up. Don't walk in with just a rate sheet and a hopeful face.

Sigmatic: The difference between those two outcomes comes down to whether you do the math before the first case or after the quarter closes. If you want to make your A S C more profitable, book a free consultation with us at sigmatic dot A I. We'll sit down with your actual spine numbers, implants and all, and show you where the margin really is. The links are in the show notes. Thanks for listening to The Margin, we'll talk again soon.

After the episode

Want a more profitable ASC?

Book a free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers, or leave your email and we will send the 2027 guide first.

Make your ASC more profitable.

A free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers: where the margin is, what to fix first. No obligation.