The Margin podcast cover art

The Margin · Analytics

ASC Payer Contracting: Using Your Own Cost per Case Data at the Table

Episode 16 · November 4, 2026 · 7 min

Walking into a payer negotiation with a fee schedule gets you a polite ask for a raise. Walking in with your own cost per case data gets you an actual seat at the table, especially now that the 2026 Medicare rule added hundreds of ASC procedures with zero commercial rate history behind them.

Chapters:
0:06 Cold Open
0:23 The Setup
1:16 The Benchmark Gap
1:45 Case Costing You Actually Need
2:35 What Changed in CY2026
3:38 What to Ask For, What to Give
4:42 Site Neutrality and Your Own Margin
6:00 This Quarter, and the Close

Free guide, The 2027 ASC State of the Union: https://sigmatic.ai/guide
Book a free consultation: https://sigmatic.ai/contact

#asc #surgerycenter #ambulatorysurgery #healthcarefinance #orutilization #ascmanagement #payercontracting #revenuecyclemanagement #surgicalcenters

Chapters

  1. 00:06 Cold Open
  2. 00:23 The Setup
  3. 01:16 The Benchmark Gap
  4. 01:45 Case Costing You Actually Need
  5. 02:35 What Changed in CY2026
  6. 03:38 What to Ask For, What to Give
  7. 04:42 Site Neutrality and Your Own Margin
  8. 06:00 This Quarter, and the Close

Transcript

Read the full transcript Every episode is transcribed, searchable, and quotable. Plain text

Sigmatic: An owner walks in with a fee schedule and a polite ask for a raise. It was a request. And it does not have to go that way, not anymore, especially with how many new procedures just got added to what Medicare will even let you bill for at a center at all.

Sigmatic: So let's set the table. Most commercial contracts price an A S C procedure as a percentage of the Medicare rate. Fine, as far as it goes, for codes both sides have billed for years and both sides trust the history on. But that pricing method falls apart the second a brand new covered procedure shows up with zero billing history behind it. A payer's analyst literally cannot price something your center has never billed before. You, on the other hand, can. You know what it costs you to put a patient through that procedure, start to finish, because you did the case. That's the whole shift we want to talk through today. Walking in with your own cost per case numbers instead of just a volume report and a request for a bump. The center that shows up with contribution margin by procedure and by payer has a position in that room. The center that only brings a fee schedule does not.

Sigmatic: Here's the gap that makes this matter, and it shows up at the industry level before it ever shows up in your specific contract. If you're negotiating from the wrong end of that range, you are negotiating from a weaker position, whether or not anyone in the room says it out loud. We've got the specialty level detail behind that spread written up separately, orthopedics, G I, ophthalmology, spine. The links are in the blog, click over and check them out.

Sigmatic: So what do you need to build before you sit down at that table. Case costing, real case costing, is the thing that turns this meeting from a request into an actual negotiation. That means knowing net revenue per case by procedure and by payer. Actual supply consumption, not what the preference card says you're supposed to use, what you actually use. Labor cost by the minute in the room. And a fair share of fixed cost spread across your scheduled O R time. Before the meeting, pull three things specifically. Contribution margin by payer and procedure, so you know which codes are underwater on which contract. Twelve months of volume by payer, matched against the new procedures your surgeons actually intend to bring in. We walk through the full method with a worked example elsewhere. I'll put the links in the description.

Sigmatic: Now, the regulatory piece, because this is the part forcing the issue whether centers are ready or not. The calendar year twenty twenty-six Medicare rule added five hundred sixty procedures to the A S C covered list. Thirty-five ancillary services got added too. Most of those five hundred sixty procedures arrived with no commercial rate attached to them at all. On top of that, the A S C payment update is two point six percent if a center meets its quality reporting requirements. Miss that reporting, and the reduction is two full percentage points off that update. Here's the part people miss. A missed quality reporting submission does not just cost you on paper. It resets the baseline that almost every commercial contract tied to a percentage of Medicare is built on. So a compliance deadline quietly becomes a payer contracting issue. Worth confirming where the calendar year twenty twenty-seven update lands against these numbers before you finalize any negotiating position.

Sigmatic: Okay, so you've got the cost data. What do you do with it at the table. A few specific asks, instead of one flat percentage across the board. Second, implant carve-outs priced at invoice plus a handling percentage. This matters a lot in orthopedics, spine, and cardiology, where implant cost alone can push supply cost toward thirty percent of revenue. Third, multi-year terms with an escalator tied to the Medicare update, so that two point six percent rate year doesn't quietly turn into a flat year three with nobody noticing. And fourth, steerage commitments, where your cost advantage over the hospital outpatient department gives the payer an actual reason to send volume your way instead of across town. What do you give back. Volume you can actually commit to and deliver on. Bundled pricing on procedures with predictable cost, cataracts, routine G I, that kind of thing. That last one is the real differentiator. A documented cost advantage is rare, and it's the thing that actually moves a renegotiation forward.

Sigmatic: One more piece of context that changes the shape of this whole conversation. Medicare policy is moving toward paying the same rate for the same service no matter where it happens, and site neutral payment for drug administration services actually expanded under this calendar year twenty twenty-six rule. Right now, hospital outpatient departments generally get paid more than A S Cs for the same procedure. That gap, the fact that the same surgery costs less at your center, is exactly what funds your pitch to a payer in the first place. As that gap narrows, hospitals have more reason to want A S C capacity for themselves, through acquisition or joint venture, which changes who's sitting across the table from you and how much room there even is to negotiate. We've got a piece on the procedure by procedure mechanics of that rate gap, and another on E B I T D A margins and where the typical leaks are, benchmarked against that revenue range we mentioned earlier. By the way, that E B I T D A spread runs from about twelve point eight percent for centers under three million dollars in revenue, up to thirty-seven point three percent for centers above nine million. I'll put the links in the description. A center that knows its own number against that range walks into a payer meeting and a joint venture conversation holding the same set of facts. Worth checking that before a renegotiation, not after.

Sigmatic: So, practically, this quarter, three steps, in order. One, cost your top twenty procedures by volume. Use actual consumption data, not the preference card, and rank them by contribution margin for each of your major payers. Two, pull twelve months of volume by payer, and flag which new procedures from this expanded covered list your surgeons are actually ready to bring into your center. Three, rank your payer contracts by dollars at stake, that's volume times the size of the rate gap, and book your first renegotiation meeting with that list sitting in front of you. Not a new strategy, just better information in the room, and that's really the whole point of this episode. Case costing flips that. If you want to make your A S C more profitable, book a free consultation with us at sigmatic dot A I. We'll sit down with your own numbers, procedure by procedure, payer by payer, and show you where the margin actually is. The links are in the show notes. Thanks for listening to The Margin, we'll talk again soon.

After the episode

Want a more profitable ASC?

Book a free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers, or leave your email and we will send the 2027 guide first.

Make your ASC more profitable.

A free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers: where the margin is, what to fix first. No obligation.