The Margin podcast cover art

The Margin · Analytics

Surgical Scheduling Software for ASCs: What to Look For and What It Cannot Fix

Episode 10 · November 4, 2026 · 8 min

Block time sits empty forty-two percent of the time even in centers already running scheduling software, and that gap is not a software problem you can buy your way out of. This episode walks through exactly what a scheduling system should show you by surgeon and by room, and where vendors quietly stop short of the answer you actually need.

Chapters:
0:02 Cold Open
0:36 The Setup
1:04 What the Software Actually Does
2:02 The Numbers It Should Show You
3:12 What It Cannot Fix
4:49 Where Scheduling Becomes Margin
5:46 What To Actually Do
7:43 Close

Free guide, The 2027 ASC State of the Union: https://sigmatic.ai/guide
Book a free consultation: https://sigmatic.ai/contact

#asc #surgerycenter #ambulatorysurgery #healthcarefinance #orutilization #ascmanagement #orscheduling #healthcareoperations #casecosting

Chapters

  1. 00:06 Cold Open
  2. 00:40 The Setup
  3. 01:08 What the Software Actually Does
  4. 02:06 The Numbers It Should Show You
  5. 03:16 What It Cannot Fix
  6. 04:53 Where Scheduling Becomes Margin
  7. 05:50 What To Actually Do
  8. 07:47 Close

Transcript

Read the full transcript Every episode is transcribed, searchable, and quotable. Plain text

Sigmatic: Here is a number that should bother you if you run an A S C. Forty-two percent of blocked O R time goes unused, on average, across more than four hundred fifty centers. That is the average across centers already running scheduling software every single day. So before you sign another contract for a shiny new system, I want you to sit with that for a second. The software did not cause that gap. And here is the uncomfortable part, the software by itself is not going to close it either.

Sigmatic: About six thousand four hundred Medicare certified A S Cs are running some version of a scheduling system right now. But ask a much simpler question. By surgeon, over the last month, was the block time they were given actually used? And if it wasn't, what did those empty minutes cost the center? That second question is the one worth answering before you buy anything new, or before you keep paying for what you already have.

Sigmatic: Let's be clear about what O R scheduling software is built to do, because it is genuinely useful, just not magic. At its core it holds the calendar. Surgeon blocks, case bookings, room assignments, the staff and equipment each case needs. A system that is working well will show you block minutes used against block minutes held, scheduled duration against what actually happened, and the turnover gap between cases, broken out by room and by day. That is the raw material. The better systems take one more step and connect to your practice management or billing system, so a scheduled case links to what it actually collected, what it actually cost in supplies, and how many staff hours it actually burned. Without that connection, you have a calendar with a report builder bolted onto it. With that connection, you finally have the starting point for real case costing.

Sigmatic: Block utilization should be sitting at seventy percent or better. Most centers are closer to that forty-two percent unused figure we opened with. First case on-time starts have a practical floor around ninety percent. The median center is sitting near sixty-four point three percent, and even the ninetieth percentile of centers only gets to eighty-eight point three percent. Turnover time should be under seven minutes for short cases and under ten for complex ones. Cases per O R per day average around four point four, though that varies a lot by specialty and how blocks are designed. And cancellation rate in A S Cs runs around one percent, compared to one point seven percent in hospitals. Now notice what is missing from that list. Cost. Your scheduling system can tell you a room sat empty for forty minutes. It cannot tell you whether that forty minutes was nine hundred dollars of lost contribution margin or one hundred twenty dollars, because that number does not come from the calendar. It comes from case costing. A system that stops at utilization is only answering half the question you actually need answered.

Sigmatic: This is the part most vendors will not say out loud, so I will. A system surfaces a number. A person has to act on it. Take the release or lose rule for unused block time, that forty-eight to seventy-two hour window after which a surgeon's unused block goes back into the pool. That is a policy decision backed by data. It is not a feature a vendor ships out of the box. We've written more on how to actually set that window and who should own enforcing it, the links are below, I will put them in the show notes. First case starts have the exact same split. Software can flag that the median center only hits sixty-four percent against a ninety percent floor. It cannot make the pre-op phone call, move a patient's arrival time earlier, or name the one person on your team who is accountable for the first case of the day. Those are staffing decisions, and we have a separate guide on exactly that. Turnover time is no different. A system can time every single turnover to the minute and show you that twenty-eight point five minute median against a sub ten minute target. It cannot pre-build the case cart the night before, stage the next patient, or run parallel room setup. Those are decisions your staff make the day before, not a toggle in a settings menu. And then there is anesthesia coverage, which is the one people forget about. A case that cannot start because anesthesia is not available usually shows up in a scheduling report as a generic unexplained delay, not as a coverage gap. If you want to actually track cases delayed for anesthesia as its own category, that is something you have to choose to build. Most off the shelf systems will not flag it for you.

Sigmatic: Here is the bigger point underneath all of this. A room can hit seventy percent utilization and still lose you money if the cases filling it run late, cancel often, or carry thin contribution margin once you account for supply and labor cost. Raw block utilization is a start, not the finish line. The more useful view blends utilization with what actually happened inside that time, on-time starts, turnover, and case mix during the hours your center is actually staffed, which is really what O R prime time utilization is getting at. None of this works, though, if your scheduling system sits off on its own island, disconnected from billing and materials data. A center that cannot connect a scheduled case to what it actually collected and what it actually cost in supplies is scheduling in the dark. It does not matter how clean the calendar looks on the screen. I'll put the links in the description if you want the fuller breakdown on how schedule, staffing, and cost all interact.

Sigmatic: So here is the checklist, and none of it requires signing anything new today. First, before you buy or renew a scheduling system, ask for a live demo built on your own case types, not a canned walkthrough. Make it show block utilization by surgeon and by month against a published target, not just a center-wide blended number. Make it show first case on-time start measured against the scheduled minute, not the room-ready minute, with the gap between the two visible on screen. Make it show turnover time by room and by case type, separated out from basic cleaning and setup. Make it show a direct link, not a manual export somebody builds in a spreadsheet, between the schedule and your billing or practice management system. And make it show a release or lose rule the system can enforce automatically at a time window you set, instead of a flag a person has to remember to check. If a vendor cannot answer those with specifics, moving your schedule from paper or a spreadsheet to a new login is not going to close the gap between forty-two percent and seventy percent by itself. And here are three things you can do this quarter without a new contract at all. Pull block utilization and first case on-time starts from whatever system you have right now, by surgeon, for the last full quarter, and compare it against seventy percent and ninety percent. The size of the gap tells you whether your problem is the software or the policy that should sit on top of it. Second, write down an actual release or lose rule, with a time window and a named owner, before you evaluate a single new platform. A system cannot automate a rule that does not exist yet. Third, ask your current vendor, or the next one you demo, to show one case's full path, from scheduled block to billed revenue to actual supply cost, on a single screen. If that path does not exist today, that is the gap worth closing first, regardless of which calendar sits on top of it.

Sigmatic: Scheduling software is a tool, not a strategy. It will tell you the truth about your block time if you ask it the right questions, but somebody still has to act on what it says. If you want to make your A S C more profitable, book a free consultation with us at sigmatic dot A I. We will go through your own numbers and show you where the margin is. The links are in the show notes. Thanks for listening to The Margin, I'll see you next time.

After the episode

Want a more profitable ASC?

Book a free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers, or leave your email and we will send the 2027 guide first.

Make your ASC more profitable.

A free 30-minute consultation on your own numbers: where the margin is, what to fix first. No obligation.